Garmin Lily 2 vs Withings ScanWatch Light

Garmin Lily 2

Garmin Lily 2

vsWithings ScanWatch Light

Withings ScanWatch Light

Garmin Lily 2Withings ScanWatch Light
DisplayTouchscreen display hidden behind a patterned lensAnalog hybrid dial with 0.63" grayscale OLED sub-display (14504 px, 282 PPI)
BodyMetal watch case; swappable Italian leather, nylon or silicone bands—
BatteryUp to 5 days in smartwatch modeUp to 30 days (launch claim; Withings now states up to 35 days), about 2 hours to charge
GPSConnected GPS (uses a compatible smartphone's GPS); no built-in GPS—
HealthBody Battery, sleep score, heart rate, stress, Pulse Ox, respiration, women's health tracking, meditation and breathwork—
Smart featuresSmart notifications, morning report, incident detection via Garmin Connect (no Garmin Pay on this model)—
ConnectivityCompatible with iPhone and Android via Garmin Connect app—
Case—37 mm (36.8 mm diameter, 9.85 mm thick), stainless steel, Gorilla Glass, 27.1 g without wristband, 18 mm FKM wristband
Water Resistance—5 ATM (50 m)
Health Sensors—Multi-wavelength PPG heart rate sensor, HDR accelerometer (no ECG, SpO2 or temperature sensor)
Features—Heart rate notifications, respiratory scan, sleep tracking, VO2 max, menstrual cycle logging, 40+ automatic activities
OS—HealthSense, iOS 15+ / Android 9+ compatible
Colours—Black, white, rose gold and white